The National Park Service has proposed a land swap with descendants of Thomas Carnegie that would allow up to eight new private homes on Cumberland Island, Ga., according to NPR. The park service has managed the island since 1972.

Under the plan, the park service would acquire private land on the island's west side, and two branches of Carnegie descendants would receive parkland for construction. Park superintendent Melissa Trenchik defended the proposal. She said the goal is to consolidate private ownership on the west side so the park can better interpret natural and cultural resources on the Atlantic side, where the government could then prohibit development. She said the homes would be "modest," subject to permanent conservation limits and no taller than 35 feet.

Critics disagree with that description. Joseph Manning, an attorney with Defenders of Wildlife, said, "We're swapping for McMansions." The source reports that the homes could include a 15,000-square-foot allowance, including driveways and outbuildings. Manning also described the deal as part of a broader pattern of land exchanges that he said benefit a small group of individuals or families rather than expanding public access. The source reports that the park service received more than 12,500 public comments on the proposal.

Barclay McFadden, a great-great-grandson of Thomas Carnegie, said the criticism is "unfounded" and that the family has protected the island. He said five generations are buried on the island and that his grandmother's generation declined to sell to developers in the 1970s. Jamie Ferguson, a Carnegie descendant who is not directly involved in the current proposal, said he trusts the family's record of protecting the island.

The source does not say when the proposal will be decided or what the final terms will be.