Mary Peltola has won Alaska's U.S. Senate race and flipped the seat into the Democrats' column, according to a race call by The Associated Press. She beat Republican Sen. Dan S. Sullivan, and with the result Democrats will hold 56 Senate seats in the upcoming Congress. The most important fact is the margin of her win: she took a majority of first-place votes, so no ranked-choice calculation was needed. In a state Trump carried by 13 percentage points in 2024, that is a striking outcome.
The report points to a clear cause. Trump's approval in Alaska and nationally has fallen since 2024, driven largely by opposition to the Iran war and anger over high prices. Peltola ran on affordability, healthcare costs and accusations of corruption, and she spoke directly to rural voters facing groceries and gas that can cost double or triple what they pay elsewhere. Sullivan, a Marine Corps veteran and steadfast Trump ally, could not outrun that drag, even after the president flew to Wasilla to rally for him. Voters in a deep-red state appear to have decided that the national mood mattered more than party loyalty.
The final days of the race raised a harder question. The New York Times reported that Peltola's team was involved in efforts to recruit a second Dan Sullivan to siphon votes from the incumbent. Peltola's campaign denied involvement, and NPR has not independently confirmed that reporting. A federal judge rejected a Justice Department lawsuit that sought to block certification, and the department says it will appeal. The judge said such an order would clearly violate Alaskan voters' right to a secret ballot, and that is the right conclusion. Alaska's governor has ordered an investigation, and that is where the question should be answered.
Alaska's rules on ballot stacking and spoilers are generally legal and have been relatively common, but that does not make them healthy. Super PACs from both parties spent more than $2 million on ballot composition this year, including elevating a federal inmate in New York who does not live in Alaska. Voters deserve a race where the candidates on the ballot are the ones they meant to choose. Lawmakers should close this gap, and the investigation should report publicly.
Peltola's win is historic: the first Democrat to take an Alaska Senate seat since 2008 and the first Alaska Native to serve in the Senate. Her victory is also the clearest sign yet that high prices and an unpopular war can reach even the reddest corners of the map. Now the state should make sure the next election is decided by voters alone.